Are vegan meat substitutes good for you?
Feb 5, 2020
With veganism now an established lifestyle choice, it seems more and more supermarket and fast food chains are releasing vegan alternatives to keep up with consumer attitudes. From Greggs’ infamous vegan sausage roll to the launch of Asda’s brand new plant-based range, it seems vegans are being catered for everywhere, including fast food chains and grab-and-go stores.
And while this is a fantastic milestone for the vegan community, I can’t help but wonder how healthy these vegan alternatives are. Are they nutritious, meat-free alternatives teeming with essential proteins and healthy fats? Or are they packed with saturated fats, sugar and salt to ensure they taste good and win over consumers? After reading that Pret’s vegan cookies contained “the same amount of fat as a McDonald’s cheeseburger”, I decided to do a little research into some of the most popular ready-to-eat vegan products and meat substitutes on the market.
Fast food meat is notorious for being pumped with preservatives, additives and excess oil to satisfy taste buds and keep customers coming back for more. But what about vegan fast food alternatives? According to Geeta Sidhu-Robb, it seems meat-free alternatives are not necessarily a ‘healthy’ alternative, but they still might be better for you than real meat versions. She told Metro: “Probably the biggest thing to be concerned about where meat-substitutes are concerned are the salt levels. Some of these products contain really high levels of sodium, so you do need to be careful when choosing a product and read all labels carefully.
“[But] in the balance of things, alternatives are actually healthier than processed meat – it just depends which substitute you opt for.”
When it comes to fat and calorie content, however, it seems vegan fast food comes in at about the same as meat products. But when we look at supermarkets, it seems meat substitutes score much better, says an article by Live Kindly.
“While Burger King’s meat-free and meat-based burgers boast similar counts of calories and fat, this is not the case for all plant-based products. British supermarket chain Iceland offers vegan ‘No Bull’ quarter-pounder patties. They contain 9 grams of fat per 100 grams, 1.4 of which are saturated. In comparison, the supermarket chain’s beef patties contain 21.8 grams of fat, 9.8 of which are saturated.”
So, as we already knew deep down, vegan fast food products are never going to be good for us. But next time you’re in a fast food restaurant, the vegan alternative may be slightly better for you.
Established before the surge in veganism, Quorn entered the market as a veggie alternative to meat but has since upped its game to offer a vegan line. Quorn products are made using a fermented mycoprotein derived from the Fusarium venenatum, a natural fungus found in soil. Egg white is usually added to the mix, but for its vegan range, potato starch and sometimes pea protein or tapioca starch are used instead. Glucose, oxygen, nitrogen and minerals are also added to create the conditions for it to convert wheat into protein.
“There is no denying that it’s a highly processed food.” Nutritionist Kim Pearson told Runner’s World. “It’s easy to make the mistake of thinking that ‘plant-based’ automatically means healthy, but the same rules apply to plant products as they do to animal products – the less processed the better.”
Kim says that while the best form of proteins are ones that occur naturally, eating Quorn once in a while is fine, but ideally, you should opt for the products that are the least processed and have the fewest added ingredients. “These tend to be the most basic Quorn pieces rather than options such as the battered replica fish fillets and pies, for example.”
For as long as veganism has been around, tofu has been a staple ingredient and easy meat alternative, especially for those just starting out with the lifestyle. However, there have been growing concerns over the years about the potential risks associated with over-consumption of soy-based products, with worries that it can affect hormone levels and even lead to breast cancer.
But many experts claim this is untrue, with scientists finding that the ingredient doesn’t contain nearly enough isoflavones to increase the risks associated with breast cancer. On the other hand, Geeta says tofu is an excellent source of protein: “Tofu is a good source of protein and contains all nine essential amino acids and acts as a valuable source of iron and calcium.
“Soy is high in polysaturated fats, fibre, vitamins and zinc which is beneficial to the immune system. On the whole, if carefully planned, meat alternatives can form the crux of a healthy diet and are far less dense in saturated fats and calorie value than meat.”
So there you have it. It seems vegan fast food is never going to be healthy (if only!) and although vegan supermarket ranges may be slightly better for us, we still have to be diligent in checking the labels for calorie, salt, sugar and saturated fat content. Like with Kolibri, the more natural the ingredients list of a vegan product is, the better it’s going to be for you.
About the author:
Kamila is a bestselling author of “Bespoke. How to radically grow your bar and restaurant business through personalisation”, and passionate trend-spotter for the UK Eating Out market with thousands of followers on her widely popular blog www.Bespoke.World.
With a decade of hands-on experience collaborating with hospitality influencers and insight experts and background in setting strategies for leading brands, Kamila has become the industry champion for truly bespoke and guest-centric experiences.
Intrigued? Learn more:
Going sober: teetotal bloggers share their stories and advice
Just starting out on your sober journey? We spoke to bloggers about what made them adopt a sober lifestyle and their tips and advice for going teetotal.Read More
Alcohol and CBD: the dos and don’ts
When starting to experiment with CBD you may be wondering how different it is to other cannabis products containing THC and whether you can take it safely with alcohol. This guide of dos and don’ts will take you through all the things you need to know about taking CBD with alcohol.Read More
Should pubs and bars be doing more to incentivise sobriety?
Drinking trends in the UK have changed considerably over the last couple of years. The mid-2000s experienced a peak in binge drinking among adolescents but ever since then, there has been a slow decline in alcohol consumption, all the way through to 2020.Read More
Are vegan meat substitutes good for you?
With meat substitutes cropping up in supermarkets and fast food chains all over the country, I wanted to find out if vegan meat is actually good for us.Read More
Who’s the BIGGEST CBD consumer? You’ll be surprised
Along with the steady growth of CBD consumers, a market predicted to grow almost 700% in 2020 to be exact, there has also been a rise in consumers who are ‘CBD curious’.Read More
CBD and its claims – which are true and which are false?
The rapid growth of CBD and the recent legalisation of its use within the NHS has placed the spotlight on the cannabinoid and the health benefits many companies seem to claim it has. It can often be hard to know who to believe when it comes to this “somewhat controversial” substance and whether labels are over-selling a product that has no real benefit to our health at all, especially for those who have never tried it before.Read More
CBD is not Bullsh*t. Current CBD Products however…
CBD is certainly a buzzword in the industry right now, and it’s something I’ve been writing about and have been interested in for some time now. As a compound, CBD is clearly having a positive effect on many people’s lives, however, as a product, it’s simply not up to scratch.Read More
How should I take CBD?
With so many CBD products on the market, it can be challenging for beginners to know which to try, and how best to use them. In this article, I explain the three main ways to administer CBD products and the benefits of each method.Read More
5 Reasons to Try CBD
Known for its abundance of health and wellbeing benefits, CBD has become a widely used product here in the UK, around 300,000 according to The Week’s recent article. Made from the chemical compound cannabidiol, CBD is found in the cannabis plant but contains no psychoactive properties, unlike its sister compound THC.Read More
How do I know if a CBD product is high quality?
For those who are new to the CBD scene, it can be a bit daunting trying to find a product that is not only right for you, but of a high quality. While checking the credibility of the seller and online reviews are a good place to start, the quality of the product you’re buying can also be determined by its certifications, extraction method, hemp plant sources and more.Read More
How CBD manufacturers compromise on quality
As I continue to dive into the new and exciting world of CBD, I find more facets of the industry that I want to explore. When looking at the more negative aspects of the product, something that comes up repeatedly is how the lack of regulation and manufacturers rushing to meet demand can cause compromise on dosage and quality within cannabidiol products.Read More
The rise of CBD drinks
This month, I want to discuss CBD and how the plant-based substance is having a huge impact on beverages. As the founder of a customisable drinks brand, I have become immersed in the community that surrounds new product trends and since the legalisation, more and more companies have hopped on board to create their own CBD inspired productsRead More
Is CBD safe?
As part of my exploration into Cannabidiol (CBD), I want to explore whether it is universally a safe option, or whether there are certain groups or demographics who should steer clear of it. Although only being sold as a food supplement currently in the UK, more and more people are using it for potential medicinal purposes.Read More
Why retailers and bars are wise to offer CBD
CBD is something I am truly fascinated with at the moment. It’s not often a new product enters the industry that has the ability to completely revolutionise it, but when it comes to CBD, I feel like this is just the beginning.Read More
CBD does nothing for me! Or does it?
CBD was one of the biggest health trends of 2019, and I'm glad to see more conversations opening up around its benefits. This fantastic product has brought relief and support to many people for a variety of reasons and it's great that it's becoming more accessible to all consumers.Read More
CBD Bad Players - WE ARE WATCHING YOU!
For those who are new to the CBD scene, it can be a bit daunting trying to find a product that is not only right for you, but of high quality. While checking the credibility of the seller and online reviews are a good place to start, the quality of the product you’re buying can also be determined by its certifications, extraction method, hemp plant sources and more.Read More
CBD - The time is now!
There is no denying that CBD has become very popular. In the UK alone, sales of CBD products has increased by 99% in 2019, with Brits rushing to invest in the ingredient that is now used in copious health and beauty products.Read More
CBD Drinks - Quality matters!
With a new CBD drink in the market every minute, it is becoming increasingly difficult to understand what differentiates one from the other. Here are a few things to keep in mind when looking for good quality CBD products.Read More
Why 2020 will change Drinking Experiences forever!
I take a look at the continuing rise of the customer experience and how this is having an impact on the importance of product prices in 2020 and beyond.Read More
Could alcohol-free bars be the answer to the UK’s rise in sobriety?
With alcohol-licensed venues closing due to plummeting drinking rates, could alcohol-free bars and nightclubs be the answer to the UK’s rising teetotalism?Read More
The top sugar-consuming nations and what they are doing to cut back
We look at three of the top sugar-loving countries in the world and what they are doing do cut back on their nation’s excessively high sugar intake.Read More
Why do social situations usually have to mean drinking?
Not all social situations have to involve alcohol. In this article I discuss the benefits a booze-free night can have on your lifestyle.Read More
Authenticity and the changing face of luxury
As brands strive to meet the increasing demands of consumers, an emphasis on authenticity and personal experiences is changing the meaning of luxury.Read More
Looking at the sugar in Christmas drinks 2018
This year I wanted to take another look at the shocking truth about sugar-laden Christmas drinks and explore whether coffee shops have tried to make a change.Read More
The future of sobriety: Alcohol-free clubs, societies and festivals
Are alcohol-free festivals like Mindful Drinking Festival, events that bring together likeminded people to celebrate not drinking, the future of sobriety?Read More
Is Pepsi buying SodaStream a clear sign that people want more customisation?
Does PepsiCo’s recent purchase of SodaStream show that even the biggest brands in the soft drinks market are hearing the call for customisation?Read More
The rising popularity of non-alcoholic beers
As people shift away from drinking, beer companies have been quick to start developing their own non-alcoholic brews in order to keep up with new demands.Read More
The truth about sugar: Should we be doing more to give it up?
It’s excellent that consumers are wising up to the potentially harmful effects of sugar. But should we be doing more to give it up?Read More
How to start catering for people who aren’t drinking
With so many people turning to sobriety, it can be hard for restaurateurs to know where to start when catering for those who aren’t drinking alcohol.Read More
Generation sober: why are millennials cutting back on alcohol?
With drinking rates among British adults at their lowest in 18 years, why aren’t millennials drinking alcohol like the generations before them?Read More
Mintel features Kolibri in its trend setters report
Kolibri Drinks is featured in the Mintel Trend setters report and describes how Kolibri has removed all the sugar from its botanical drinks using a new bottle format that allows consumers to control how sweet their drink is.Read More
How should the bar industry entice customers away from the sofa?
Although millennials are not as interested in staying home as older people, traditional pubs and bars should be concerned. Younger consumers are drinking less alcohol and seeking out fresh and exciting experiences.Read More
Other countries taking up the mantle of the sugar tax
Since the Soft Drinks Industry Levy was introduced in the UK in April 2018, other countries have started taking up the mantle of the sugar tax.Read More
Are adult milkshakes a push back against the clean eating trend?
Replica American diners are popping up all over the UK and with this trend comes a barrage of sugar-laden milkshakes. Topped with Oreos, sweets and even doughnuts, milkshakes are having their moment in the spotlight.Read More
Should we be scared of artificial sweeteners?
Artificial sweeteners are making the headlines again, and not for the right reasons. There are millions of consumers worldwide who happily drink diet fizzy drinks which seem virtuous because they replace sugar but in reality maybe the artificial additives are not as helpful as we imagine.Read More
Soft drinks sugar solutions post sugar tax
The sugar tax has been hotly debated since it was first mentioned back in 2016 but now, two years on, it has come into action and divided not only the nation, but the entirety of the soft drink industry. While many people are throwing accusations of Nanny State, others are likening it to the taxation of the Tobacco industry.Read More